Holdings overlap analysis · SEC EDGAR + issuer data Updated daily

VTV vs XLU

Holdings Overlap Analysis

Weight Overlap
4.8%
Shared Holdings
26 / 315
Unique to VTV
282
Unique to XLU
7
Quick Verdict

VTV and XLU are largely complementary, with only 4.8% weighted overlap. Pairing them is an effective way to diversify across different segments of the market.

What each fund holds

VTV Vanguard Value ETF

VTV holds about 300 large US companies that screen as value on the CRSP US Large Cap Value index, making it the biggest value ETF and a common partner to a growth fund.

Tracks the CRSP US Large Cap Value · Full replication · 1940 Act

Full profile of VTV
XLU Utilities Select Sector SPDR Fund

XLU holds the roughly 30 utility companies in the S&P 500, led by NextEra Energy, Southern and Duke, in the Select Sector SPDR for utilities.

Tracks the Utilities Select Sector · Full replication · 1940 Act

Full profile of XLU
Diversification
95
out of 100

Analysis

By weight, about 4.8% of VTV and XLU is identical, across 26 common holdings. That gives a diversification score of 95/100 — the two are largely complementary.

Their top 10 positions account for 24% of VTV and 59% of XLU, making XLU the more concentrated of the two. The widest sector gap is Utilities, where XLU is overweight by roughly 95.0 percentage points.

Adding XLU on top of VTV introduces 7 holdings you don't already own — names like Atmos Energy (ATO), Evergy (EVRG), NRG Energy (NRG).

Side-by-side

VTVXLU
NameVanguard Value ETFUtilities Select Sector SPDR Fund
IssuerVanguardState Street
TracksCRSP US Large Cap ValueUtilities Select Sector
Structure1940 Act, US1940 Act, US
AUM$130.0B$16.0B
Expense ratio0.04%0.09%
Holdings30833
Holdings as ofNov 9, 2026Nov 9, 2026

Top Shared Holdings

# Ticker Name Weight A Weight B Sector
1 NEE NextEra Energy Inc. 0.65% 13.52% Utilities
2 SO Southern Co. 0.40% 7.89% Utilities
3 DUK Duke Energy Corp. 0.37% 7.45% Utilities
4 CEG Constellation Energy Corp. 0.30% 5.80% Utilities
5 AEP American Electric Power Co. Inc. 0.28% 5.07% Utilities
6 SRE Sempra Energy 0.23% 3.83% Utilities
7 D Dominion Energy Inc. 0.22% 4.50% Utilities
8 ETR Entergy Corp. 0.21% 3.78% Utilities
9 VST Vistra Energy Corp. 0.20% 2.62% Utilities
10 XEL Xcel Energy Inc. 0.19% 3.69% Utilities
11 EXC Exelon Corp. 0.18% 3.53% Utilities
12 ED Consolidated Edison Inc. 0.15% 3.30% Utilities
13 PEG Public Service Enterprise Group Inc. 0.15% 2.68% Utilities
14 WEC WEC Energy Group Inc. 0.14% 2.83% Utilities
15 PCG PG&E Corp. 0.13% 2.14% Utilities
16 AEE Ameren Corp. 0.12% 2.29% Utilities
17 CNP CenterPoint Energy Inc. 0.11% 1.93% Utilities
18 EIX Edison International 0.11% 1.72% Utilities
19 ES Eversource Energy 0.10% 1.99% Utilities
20 DTE DTE Energy Co. 0.10% 2.06% Utilities
21 FE FirstEnergy Corp. 0.10% 1.78% Utilities
22 PPL PPL Corp. 0.10% 1.99% Utilities
23 AWK American Water Works Co. Inc. 0.10% 2.22% Utilities
24 CMS CMS Energy Corp. 0.09% 1.61% Utilities
25 NI NiSource Inc 0.04% 1.57% Utilities
Showing 25 of 25

Biggest Weight Differences

Stocks both funds hold, but at very different weights — where the two ETFs tilt apart.

Holding VTV XLU Diff
NEE NextEra Energy Inc. 0.65% 13.52% -12.87
SO Southern Co. 0.40% 7.89% -7.48
DUK Duke Energy Corp. 0.37% 7.45% -7.08
CEG Constellation Energy Corp. 0.30% 5.80% -5.50
AEP American Electric Power Co. Inc. 0.28% 5.07% -4.79
D Dominion Energy Inc. 0.22% 4.50% -4.27
SRE Sempra Energy 0.23% 3.83% -3.61
ETR Entergy Corp. 0.21% 3.78% -3.58
XEL Xcel Energy Inc. 0.19% 3.69% -3.50
EXC Exelon Corp. 0.18% 3.53% -3.35

Unique Holdings

Stocks held by only one of the two funds — the exposure you gain (or lose) by switching.

Only in VTV 282 holdings

MU Micron Technology Inc 4.87%
JPM JPMorgan Chase & Co. 3.06%
BRK.B Berkshire Hathaway Inc. Clas... 2.95%
JNJ Johnson & Johnson 2.29%
XOM ExxonMobil Holdings Corp. 2.12%
WMT Walmart Inc. 1.86%
CAT Caterpillar Inc. 1.83%
ABBV AbbVie Inc. 1.66%
CSCO Cisco Systems Inc 1.56%
UNH UnitedHealth Group Inc. 1.41%
BAC Bank of America Corp. 1.36%
HD Home Depot Inc. 1.32%
PG Procter & Gamble Co. 1.28%
MRK Merck & Co. Inc. 1.19%
CVX Chevron Corp. 1.17%

Only in XLU 7 holdings

ATO Atmos Energy Corp 2.17%
EVRG Evergy Inc 1.48%
NRG NRG Energy Inc 1.24%
PNW Pinnacle West Capital Corp 0.92%
AES AES Corp/The 0.78%
- SSI US GOV MONEY MARKET CLAS... 0.17%
IXSZ6 XAU UTILITIES DEC26 0.01%

Concentration & Sector Tilt

How top-heavy each fund is, and which sectors each one leans into. Sector weights are our own roll-up of the GICS sector on each holding in the issuer's holdings file, so they can differ slightly from the issuer's factsheet.

VTV Top 10
23.6%
of portfolio
XLU Top 10
59.1%
of portfolio

Top 10 is measured against the full fund, not rescaled to the equity sleeve, and each share class (for example Alphabet A and C) counts as a separate holding. Issuer factsheets that combine share classes and exclude cash and currency forwards from the denominator can show a figure about a point higher.

SectorOverweightBy
Utilities XLU +95.0 pts
Financials VTV +22.6 pts
Health Care VTV +15.1 pts
Industrials VTV +15.0 pts
Information Technology VTV +13.9 pts
Consumer Staples VTV +8.7 pts
Energy VTV +6.8 pts
Consumer Discretionary VTV +3.9 pts

Sector Overlap

Utilities 4.8%

FAQ

VTV and XLU share 4.8% weight overlap and 26 common holdings.

Yes, this pairing makes sense for diversification — overlap is low (4.8%), so each fund contributes distinct exposure.

VTV tracks the CRSP US Large Cap Value by full replication. It is a 1940 Act fund domiciled in US that pays out dividends. XLU tracks the Utilities Select Sector by full replication. It is a 1940 Act fund domiciled in US that pays out dividends. The two indexes define different universes, which is where the holdings that only one fund owns come from.

Share & Embed

Writing about VTV vs XLU? You're welcome to use this chart or the live widget in your article — just link back to this page as the source.

Interactive widget that always shows current overlap data:

Static chart image (works on Substack, Medium, forums):

Live preview:

Related Comparisons