Holdings overlap analysis · SEC EDGAR + issuer data Updated daily

Are Your Two 'Different' Growth ETFs the Same Bet? VUG vs QQQ vs SCHG

Owning VUG, QQQ, and SCHG together feels diversified, but all three are dominated by the same mega-cap tech names.

If you own two large-cap growth ETFs and feel diversified, it's worth a closer look. Many DIY investors hold some combination of VUG, QQQ, and SCHG thinking each brings something different to the table. In practice, all three are dominated by the same handful of mega-cap technology names, and they tend to move together more than their labels suggest.

This is a theme teardown: what these funds actually hold, how much they overlap, and why subtle index-construction differences don't rescue you from concentration.


The same top 10, over and over


The core problem is concentration at the top. Each of these growth funds points its heaviest weights at roughly the same names:

  1. Apple
  2. Microsoft
  3. Nvidia
  4. Amazon
  5. Meta
  6. Alphabet (Class A and C)
  7. Broadcom / Tesla rounding out the group

Across VUG, QQQ, and SCHG, these same top holdings routinely make up somewhere in the neighborhood of 50-60% of each fund's total weight (approximate, and it shifts as prices move). When your top-10 lists are nearly identical and each one dominates half the portfolio, the funds are effectively different wrappers around the same bet.


How much do they actually overlap?


Weight overlap between these three is high. Based on their published holdings:

  1. VUG vs QQQ — meaningful shared exposure in mega-cap tech, though VUG holds far more names. See the full breakdown on VUG vs QQQ.
  2. VUG vs SCHG — arguably the closest pair of the three, since both are broad large-cap growth benchmarks. Compare them at VUG vs SCHG.
  3. QQQ vs SCHG — high top-heavy overlap despite different index rules. Details at QQQ vs SCHG.

The percentages differ, but the story doesn't: the top of each fund is crowded with the same stocks. Holding two of these together mostly doubles down on the names you already own.


They also overlap with your S&P 500 fund


Here's the part investors often miss. A plain S&P 500 fund like VOO is already roughly a third weighted toward the same mega-cap technology leaders. So a growth ETF isn't adding a genuinely new asset class on top of your core index fund — it's amplifying a slice you already hold.

Check VOO vs VUG or QQQ vs VOO and you'll see substantial shared weight. If your portfolio is VOO plus QQQ plus VUG, you may be far more concentrated in a few companies than you realize.


Why they feel different: three different indexes


Each fund tracks a different benchmark, which is where the illusion of diversification comes from.


QQQ — Nasdaq-100

QQQ tracks the 100 largest non-financial companies listed on the Nasdaq. It's not technically a "growth" index — it's an exchange-listing index — but the Nasdaq's composition leans heavily tech and excludes financials entirely. That gives it a distinct flavor, but the biggest names still dominate.


VUG — CRSP US Large Cap Growth

VUG uses the CRSP methodology, which sorts large-cap stocks by growth factors (earnings growth, sales growth, and more) and can hold several hundred names. It's broader and includes companies from more sectors, but the market-cap weighting still funnels weight to the giants.


SCHG — Dow Jones US Large-Cap Growth

SCHG tracks a Dow Jones growth index with its own factor screens. Different rules, similar result: the mega-caps float to the top.

The construction differences are real, but they mostly affect the long tail of small positions — not the top 10 that drive returns. That's why these funds' performance charts tend to overlap so tightly.


A rule of thumb: pick one growth tilt


If you want a growth tilt on top of a total-market or S&P 500 core, the practical answer is usually simple: pick one.

  1. Want a tech-forward, concentrated tilt? QQQ (or its cheaper sibling QQQM) leans hardest into that theme.
  2. Want a broad, low-cost large-cap growth sleeve? VUG or SCHG do essentially the same job at low expense ratios.
  3. Already hold VOO or VTI? Understand that you already own these leaders — a growth ETF concentrates, it doesn't diversify.

Stacking two or three growth funds rarely improves diversification. It usually just increases single-stock risk and makes your portfolio harder to track. If you're aiming for genuine diversification, the more effective move is adding something with low overlap — value, small-cap, or international exposure — rather than a second growth fund.


Before you decide, run the actual numbers on the pairs you own: VUG vs QQQ, VUG vs SCHG, and QQQ vs SCHG. Seeing the shared weight in black and white tends to settle the question fast.


Not investment advice — for educational purposes only. Check the overlap comparisons and decide what fits your own plan.


Related overlap breakdowns


Related guides

Educational content only — not investment advice. See our disclaimer.