Holdings overlap analysis · SEC EDGAR + issuer data Updated daily

Where State Street's SPDR Core ETFs Overlap: SPLG, SPTM, SPYG, SPYV and SPDW

A plain-English teardown of State Street's low-cost SPDR Portfolio building blocks and how SPLG, SPTM, SPYG, SPYV and SPDW overlap.

State Street's SPDR Portfolio lineup is its answer to the ultra-cheap core building blocks from Vanguard, iShares, Schwab, and Fidelity. The tickers are unfamiliar to many DIY investors because the marketing spotlight usually lands on the flagship SPY. But the low-cost SPDR Portfolio funds — SPLG, SPTM, SPYG, SPYV, and SPDW — are the ones you'd actually use to build a diversified portfolio without paying up.

Here's how these pieces relate, where they duplicate each other, and where they genuinely complement one another.

The lineup at a glance

  1. SPLG — SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 ETF (large-cap core)
  2. SPTM — SPDR Portfolio S&P 1500 Composite (total US market)
  3. SPYG — SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 Growth
  4. SPYV — SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 Value
  5. SPDW — SPDR Portfolio Developed World ex-US (international)

Only one of these — SPLG — currently has a dedicated page on our tool, so we'll anchor the comparisons through SPLG and its close cousins where possible.

SPTM largely contains SPLG

SPTM tracks the S&P Composite 1500, which is the S&P 500 plus the S&P MidCap 400 and SmallCap 600. Because the index is market-cap weighted, the 500 largest companies dominate the fund. In practice, roughly 80%+ of SPTM's weight is the same large-cap names that make up SPLG.

That means holding both SPTM and SPLG is highly redundant. You're paying twice for the same Apple, Microsoft, and Nvidia exposure, and only the thin sliver of mid- and small-caps in SPTM is doing anything different. If you want total-market coverage, SPTM alone does the job. If you only want large caps, SPLG alone does the job. Owning both mostly just complicates rebalancing.

This is the same relationship you see between other core pairs — a total-market fund almost fully swallowing an S&P 500 fund. It mirrors what happens with ITOT vs IVV in the iShares family and SCHB vs SCHX at Schwab.

SPYG + SPYV rebuild SPLG

The S&P 500 Growth (SPYG) and S&P 500 Value (SPYV) indexes are two halves of the same parent. S&P splits every S&P 500 company into a growth bucket, a value bucket, or a blend of both based on style scores. Put SPYG and SPYV together in market-cap proportion and you reconstruct something very close to the full S&P 500.

That has two implications:

  1. SPYG and SPYV are complementary, not redundant. Their holdings barely overlap because a stock is sorted into one style or the other. Approximate overlap between a growth and value slice of the same index is low — often in the low-teens percent, driven only by the names that straddle both buckets.
  2. Owning SPYG + SPYV + SPLG is circular. If you already hold SPLG, adding both style funds just re-splits what you already own. You'd only tilt if you deliberately overweight one style — say, more SPYV for a value lean.

You can see the same growth-versus-value split dynamic in the iShares pair IVE vs IVW and, at the total-market level, in VTV vs VUG. The pattern is identical: two low-overlap halves that add back up to the whole.

SPDW is the piece that actually adds something new

SPDW is the only fund here that gives you exposure the others don't. It tracks developed international markets outside the US — Japan, the UK, Europe, Australia, Canada. None of those companies appear in the US-only SPLG, SPTM, SPYG, or SPYV.

So a clean two-fund SPDR core could be:

  1. SPTM (or SPLG) for US stocks
  2. SPDW for developed international stocks

SPDW is nearly interchangeable with Vanguard's developed-markets fund. If you're weighing State Street against Vanguard on the international side, the holdings are close enough that cost and tracking are the deciding factors — see SPDW vs VEA to gauge just how similar developed-ex-US funds are across issuers.

How SPDR stacks up against other issuers' cores

State Street's S&P 500 fund is functionally the same product as everyone else's. SPLG holds the identical 500 companies as Vanguard's and iShares' flagships, so overlap runs near 100%. If you're deciding between them, look at SPLG vs VOO — the holdings are effectively a match, and the meaningful differences are expense ratio, share price (SPLG trades at a low per-share price, handy for precise dollar amounts), and how the fund is structured.

The broader takeaway: at the S&P 500 level, the fund families are commodities. IVV vs VOO shows the same near-total overlap between iShares and Vanguard. Once holdings are identical, the only lever left is cost.

Redundant vs complementary: the quick map

  1. Redundant: SPLG + SPTM (SPTM already contains SPLG)
  2. Redundant: SPLG + SPYG + SPYV (the style halves rebuild SPLG)
  3. Complementary: SPYG + SPYV (low overlap, together they equal the 500)
  4. Complementary: any US fund + SPDW (no shared holdings)

Cost is the real differentiator

When two funds hold the same securities in the same weights, performance differences come down to fees and tracking, not stock picking. The SPDR Portfolio series was built to be price-competitive with the cheapest Vanguard and Schwab options, which is exactly why it's a reasonable core. Before you assume your funds are diversifying you, check whether they're really just charging you twice for the same basket — run the tickers through the overlap tool and let the numbers decide.

Not investment advice.


Related overlap breakdowns


Related guides

Educational content only — not investment advice. See our disclaimer.