Holdings overlap analysis · SEC EDGAR + issuer data Updated daily

Dividend ETF Overlap: Do SCHD, VYM, and DGRO Hold the Same Stocks?

A teardown of how much Schwab's SCHD, Vanguard's VYM, and iShares' DGRO actually overlap, and why owning two often duplicates the same dividend payers.

If you build an income sleeve from dividend ETFs, there's a good chance you've considered owning more than one. Schwab's SCHD, Vanguard's VYM, and iShares' DGRO are the three most popular US dividend funds, and pairing them feels like prudent diversification. The problem: all three fish from a similar pond of US large-cap dividend payers, so two of them often hold the same banks, drugmakers, and consumer staples while you think you've spread your bets.

Here's what the holdings actually show, and how to decide whether you need one dividend fund or three.

Why these three funds look so similar

Each fund starts from roughly the same universe — profitable, established US companies that pay dividends — and applies a screen. That shared starting point is why headline overlap numbers run higher than many investors expect.

  1. SCHD screens for quality plus a sustainable, growing dividend, then weights by a fundamental score. It's concentrated, around 100 holdings.
  2. VYM casts a wider net for above-average yield, holding 400-plus names, market-cap weighted.
  3. DGRO targets dividend growth — companies with a history of raising payouts — and holds several hundred names.

Different rulebooks, but they keep landing on the same large, cash-generative companies: JPMorgan, AbbVie, Coca-Cola, Home Depot, and similar mega-cap dividend payers.

How much do SCHD, VYM, and DGRO overlap?

Overlap by weight matters more than overlap by name count, because a fund can share dozens of tiny positions that barely move the needle. When you measure by weight:

  1. SCHD vs VYM typically shares a meaningful chunk of weight — roughly half — across financials, healthcare, and consumer staples, even though VYM holds four times as many stocks.
  2. SCHD vs DGRO overlaps somewhat less by weight, because DGRO's growth screen keeps it closer to the broad market and pulls in some lower-yielding names SCHD excludes.
  3. VYM vs DGRO tends to show the highest name overlap of the three, since both hold hundreds of large caps — but the weighting differences still create real tilt.

Treat these as approximate. The exact figures shift each time the underlying indexes reconstitute, but the pattern is stable: substantial shared weight in the same handful of sectors.

Where the methodology actually creates a difference

The overlap is high, but it isn't 100%, and the gaps are where each fund earns its identity.

Yield vs. growth

VYM leans into higher current yield. DGRO leans into companies that raise dividends, which often means accepting a lower starting yield in exchange for growth. SCHD tries to thread both with a quality filter. So a VYM-heavy portfolio reaches for income today; a DGRO-heavy one bets on rising payouts.

Sector tilt

SCHD's concentrated, score-weighted approach can produce outsized stakes in a few sectors — it has historically tilted toward consumer staples, healthcare, and industrials, with light technology exposure. DGRO carries more tech and financials because dividend growers skew that way. VYM sits in between with broad financials and energy weight. These tilts are the part you're actually diversifying when you add a second fund — but they're a smaller share of the portfolio than the shared core.

How dividend funds overlap with a plain S&P 500 fund

Here's the part that surprises people. Because all three funds hold large US companies, they share a lot of ground with a vanilla index fund. Compare SCHD vs VOO or VYM vs VOO and you'll see a real slice of the same mega-caps, just at different weights and minus the non-dividend growth names.

If you already own a total-market or S&P 500 fund — VOO, VTI, or IVV — a dividend ETF is a tilt on top of holdings you partly own already, not a separate asset class. That's worth knowing before you decide how big the dividend sleeve should be. For reference, the broad-market cores are nearly interchangeable themselves, as IVV vs VOO makes clear.

Practical takeaway: pick one core dividend ETF

Stacking two dividend ETFs usually buys you redundancy plus a little tilt, not true diversification. A cleaner approach:

  1. Want higher current income? Lean toward VYM's broad high-yield approach.
  2. Want rising payouts and lower turnover risk? DGRO's dividend-growth screen fits.
  3. Want a quality filter and concentration? SCHD splits the difference and is the most distinctive of the three.

Choose one as your core, size it deliberately against your broad-market holdings, and skip the second dividend fund unless you can point to a specific exposure it adds that your core lacks. Before you commit, run the exact pair through the tool — start with SCHD vs VYM and SCHD vs DGRO — and check each against your S&P 500 holding so you can see exactly how much new ground a second fund actually covers.

Not investment advice. This article is for educational purposes only; do your own research before making investment decisions.


Related overlap breakdowns


Related guides

Educational content only — not investment advice. See our disclaimer.