Holdings overlap analysis · SEC EDGAR + issuer data Updated daily

Bond ETF Overlap: Do BND, AGG, and SCHZ Hold the Same Aggregate Index Twice?

BND, AGG, and SCHZ all track near-identical aggregate bond benchmarks, so owning two is a cost decision, not diversification.

If you hold a total bond market fund and are thinking about adding a second one for "diversification," it's worth understanding what these funds actually own. The three biggest names in the category — Vanguard's BND, iShares' AGG, and Schwab's SCHZ — are built on the same idea and, in practice, hold nearly the same portfolio. Stacking two of them mostly duplicates a single sleeve rather than expanding it.

Note: BND, AGG, SCHZ, GOVT, VGIT, VCIT, and LQD do not have dedicated pages on this site, so we describe them directly here and link to related equity and sector overlaps you can inspect with the tool.

Same benchmark, three tickers

BND tracks a broad float-adjusted U.S. investment-grade bond index. AGG tracks the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index. SCHZ tracks the same aggregate family. These benchmarks are close cousins — same universe of taxable, investment-grade, dollar-denominated bonds — so the funds end up with:

  1. Roughly the same issuer mix. All three are heavy in U.S. Treasuries and agency mortgage-backed securities, with a smaller slice of investment-grade corporates.
  2. Similar maturity and duration. Intermediate-term, typically around a 6-year effective duration, with comparable interest-rate sensitivity.
  3. Similar credit quality. Overwhelmingly AAA/AA (government and agency paper), with corporate exposure concentrated in the higher investment-grade tiers.

The differences that remain are largely mechanical: index-provider methodology, sampling choices, and expense ratios. On a holdings basis these funds overlap heavily — the practical takeaway is that owning two is a cost decision, not a diversification move.

Where the real government tilt hides

The single most important thing to understand about aggregate bond funds is how government-heavy they are. A large majority of an aggregate index is Treasuries plus agency MBS. Corporate bonds are the minority. So when someone owns two aggregate funds, the bulk of what they're duplicating is a Treasury-and-mortgage core — not a diversified spread of credit exposures.

That matters because your "bond diversification" may already be more concentrated in government paper than you think. Adding a second aggregate fund doesn't fix that; it just doubles the same government-heavy sleeve.

How Treasury-only and corporate funds differ

To actually change your bond exposure — rather than duplicate it — you'd reach for funds that carve out one slice of the market:

Treasury-only funds

  1. GOVT holds U.S. Treasuries across the curve. It strips out the corporate and mortgage pieces of an aggregate index.
  2. VGIT holds intermediate-term Treasuries specifically, tightening the duration band.

Pairing an aggregate fund with a Treasury fund doesn't add much new — you're layering more government exposure onto a portfolio that's already government-heavy. It mostly increases your Treasury weighting and reduces credit exposure.

Corporate-only funds

  1. VCIT holds intermediate-term investment-grade corporate bonds.
  2. LQD holds broad investment-grade corporates across maturities.

These are where stacking can genuinely shift your risk profile. Adding a corporate fund to an aggregate fund raises your credit exposure and yield, while modestly increasing sensitivity to corporate spread widening. That's a deliberate tilt — not a duplicate.

When stacking adds something (and when it doesn't)

  1. BND + AGG or BND + SCHZ: essentially the same portfolio twice. No new diversification; pick the cheaper or more convenient one.
  2. Aggregate + GOVT/VGIT: increases Treasury weight, reduces credit. Useful only if you specifically want less corporate risk.
  3. Aggregate + VCIT/LQD: adds credit and yield. This is the case where a second fund meaningfully changes your exposure.

The pattern here mirrors what we see constantly on the equity side. Two funds tracking the same benchmark overlap almost completely — the same way IVV vs VOO shows near-total overlap because both track the S&P 500, or how QQQ vs QQQM are functionally identical portfolios at different price points. Aggregate bond funds are the fixed-income version of that story.

The Boglehead takeaway

For a buy-and-hold investor, one broad aggregate bond fund usually covers the entire U.S. investment-grade market — Treasuries, agency MBS, and corporates in one wrapper. That's the whole point of an aggregate index. You generally don't need a second one, and adding it is closer to holding the same index twice than to spreading risk.

If you decide you want to tilt — more Treasuries for safety, or more corporates for yield — do it deliberately with a targeted fund, and size it so it actually moves the needle. Otherwise, choose your single core bond fund on cost, tax location, and convenience within your brokerage.

The same discipline applies to your equity sleeve. If you hold multiple total-market or large-cap funds, it's worth checking how much they truly duplicate. Comparisons like VTI vs VOO, ITOT vs VOO, or SCHB vs VTI reveal how much redundancy already sits in a typical portfolio — and where a second fund adds nothing but complexity.

Bottom line: with aggregate bond ETFs, treat a second holding as a cost-and-convenience choice, not a diversification win. Real diversification comes from adding a different slice of the bond market, not another copy of the same one.

Not investment advice. This article is for educational purposes only; do your own research before making investment decisions.


Related overlap breakdowns


Related guides

  • Growth vs Value ETF Overlap Why style ETFs from the same index family can still overlap — and when they truly diverge.
  • Dividend ETF Overlap Dividend funds can overlap with each other and with the broad market — how to check before you stack them.

Educational content only — not investment advice. See our disclaimer.